Skip to product information
1 of 7


Mystery Bag Enamel Pins (B Grade / Seconds)

Mystery Bag Enamel Pins (B Grade / Seconds)

Regular price $20.00 USD
Sale price $20.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Each mystery bag contains 3 slightly flawed enamel pins. 

Since they are at random, you may receive duplicates if you purchase more than 1 mystery bag of the same series.

You can choose whether you would like to receive random pins from a specific series (i.e. anime soldiers, sorcerers, slayers).

Pin Specifications

  • Quantity: (3) hard enamel pins
  • Size: 1.5 in (38 mm) - 2 in (50 mm)
  • Finish: Gold metal plated
  • 2 rubber backing clutches (colors vary)
  • Logo backstamp

B GRADE / SECONDS quality pins have slightly more noticeable flaws that vary depending on the design, which is why they are at a discount.

Some examples include:
-Missing / tainted plating
-Scuffed / scratched enamel
-Under-filled / over-filled enamel

I do NOT take pin requests for these since they're all made ahead of time.

By purchasing a seconds pin from this listing, you agree and accept that you will be receiving a pin with flaws.


Due to high quantities of orders, processing your order may take 1-2 weeks. This does not include shipping time. By placing an order you agree to this timeline.

We use USPS for all shipments (domestic and International) and you will receive an automated email with tracking info when your order is shipped. For ita bag orders, we will ship via UPS.

Please check out our Shipping Policies for more details and common questions.

Return policy

We do not offer any exchanges, returns, or refunds of any kind for any product listed on

Please email if you receive any damaged or wrong item within 21 business days (3 weeks) since the ship date to adjust any issue you may have. We cannot assist you after 21 business days (3 weeks) or if the item has been used.

Pin Grading System

Pins are all handmade, making each one "one of a kind." Please refer to the descriptions below for more detailed information on how I grade my pins.

Standard Grade

Very little to almost no flaws. From a distance of about 6 inches or less, you likely won't notice anything wrong with the pins. They may have slightly lower filled enamel, small scratches on the metal, etc. but are not very noticeable.

I do not sell "perfect" collector's grade pins. Pins may appear to have very small flaws that naturally occur due to production. However, the flaws may not be noticeable at first glance unless you stare closely.

B Grade (a.k.a. "seconds")

Slight discount due to more visible flaws. May include some noticeable dust particles trapped inside the enamel, lower filled enamel, small nicks in the enamel, scratches on the enamel, or slightly slanted posts. Can be noticed from a distance or if you stare too long.
View full details

Customer Reviews

Based on 2 reviews
emily wilson
Loved the surprise!!

I ordered both the aot and jjk mystery bags and was super pleased with the results. Even with the B grade level they still looked fantastic. Would purchase again!

Cat Ross
These were B Grades?!

Seriously, I was so blown away at the amazing quality of these!! These pins are now a staple on my apron at work, I get compliments on them all the time! I love the different designs that I got from the chibi soldier and chibi sorcerer bags & the quality is 12/10!! I'm definitely going to be ordering more from this artist!! (I got Mikasa and Gojo pins as well but they're currently on my apron so they aren't pictured!)